View Single Post
Old 01-21-2009, 10:28 AM   #8 (permalink)
OhShoot
TGO Senior Member
 
OhShoot's Avatar
 
 
Joined: Jun 2008
Where: Knoxville
Age: 61
Posts: 5,191
 
OhShoot is a male OhShoot is a Carry Permit Holder OhShoot is a member of the NRA
Quote:
Originally Posted by bkelm18 View Post
If you want to argue about by all means go ahead good sir. But last time I checked, our right to carry a firearm is granted by the state, not by the constitution. Sure it says to bear arms, but go out with a pistol on your hip without a permit and we'll see how that argument stands up in court.
You are correct as to real world practices.

States and cities DO infringe that right.

And not all states infringe that right equally: there are a number of states where you CAN "go out with a pistol on your hip without a permit". Though, interestingly, they insist you can't do the same in a concealed manner without a state granted privilege (permit).

I, and most constitutionalists, would argue that firearm carry is indeed a constitutionally granted right.

Of course I agree that might makes right in real world sense.
How a municipality can decree that one can't own a handgun AT ALL is just beyond the pale.

- OS
 
__________________
 


OhShoot is online now   Reply With Quote