Jump to content

I Gotta Fever , And The Only Cure Is ....


Recommended Posts

I believe that's a 100 round drum in the pic which adds about $450 to the price , the way most are sold is with a 50 drum and 30 stick. I'm ready to get one but I'm not sure where I'm getting it from yet. I believe the best price I saw the other day was around $1,100.
Link to comment
I've got a nice one, deluxe kit with original factory custom fit case, drum mag, several stick mags in both sizes, several vintage WWII mags and original WWII mag pouches, military cleaning kit, and optional factory violin case too. I was thrilled to get it, shot it only a few times, cleaned it with a microscope, and has been in the safe ever since.

I have to admit it's cool to have, but it is also not as nice or as much fun as I had envisioned. It's extremely heavy unloaded, and an absolute anvil when loaded especially with a full drum. Cleaning is a pain if you do it right, especially the mags. And the bullets travel so slow out the long barrel that you can actually see them on the way to the target. Accuracy is marginal, and decent ammo is not so cheap anymore. Loading the drum mags is tedious, and if you don't do it right they won't run properly.

Not trying to discourage you, just suggesting that it's not worth paying a small fortune for 1 unless you really want a good looking safe queen.
Link to comment

I've got a nice one, deluxe kit with original factory custom fit case, drum mag, several stick mags in both sizes, several vintage WWII mags and original WWII mag pouches, military cleaning kit, and optional factory violin case too. I was thrilled to get it, shot it only a few times, cleaned it with a microscope, and has been in the safe ever since.

I have to admit it's cool to have, but it is also not as nice or as much fun as I had envisioned. It's extremely heavy unloaded, and an absolute anvil when loaded especially with a full drum. Cleaning is a pain if you do it right, especially the mags. And the bullets travel so slow out the long barrel that you can actually see them on the way to the target. Accuracy is marginal, and decent ammo is not so cheap anymore. Loading the drum mags is tedious, and if you don't do it right they won't run properly.

Not trying to discourage you, just suggesting that it's not worth paying a small fortune for 1 unless you really want a good looking safe queen.


Ok...now that you've ruined it for us all. Why do you still have it? LOL

Just kidding. My father-in-law has one. I think it's been out of the safe twice since getting it.

Lots of fun. Costly to shoot these days. And as you say, heavy on the cleaning and loading time.
  • Like 1
Link to comment
Guest mechanically

I was REALLY surprised at how difficult these are to control in full-auto. They just walk all over the place. You'd think as heavy as they are, they'd just sit in place while they pop away, but it takes a lot of work to keep them from running away from you. 

Link to comment

I was REALLY surprised at how difficult these are to control in full-auto. They just walk all over the place. You'd think as heavy as they are, they'd just sit in place while they pop away, but it takes a lot of work to keep them from running away from you.


But the recoil is a pleasure :)
Link to comment

 At that price I am guessing you are looking at the ones by Auto Ordnance now being made by Khar. If so My brother in law bought one last year. I had always wanted one also but that idea is long gone now. 

 

 Other than the normal complaint , VERY HEAVY , it is also VERY hard to cock and put a round in the chamber . The spring pressure is unreal . His has been pretty bad to jam as well . First I found a bur on the extractor that helped but he still has problems with one of the magazines. To me the barrel is too long because of the NFA  and it just doesn't have the look in person of the real thing. It still looks good but I kept saying , something just doesn't look right.

 

  He probably should have been sent back for repair but after a little research on google he just kept trying this and that and it does OK now but it is not great. Seems the problems are common and that sending it back for repair seldom got them repaired. He did buy a drum magazine but then had problems with the bolt staying back after almost every shot. I contacted Khar by email and the only reply was send it in for repair , so they might have fixed it but he did not want to send it back . He had to replace the spring for the bolt hold open . This was a new gun not used and he has finally gotten around 400 rounds through it. It does work better with the drum now than the stick magazine.

 

 Would he buy one again ? NO way . Would I buy one ? I had always wanted one and several years ago I had the money with me and found one. I picked it up , looked it over and held it for a while . Too heavy for me and I walked away with the money still in my pocket. After shooting his and seeing the problems his has had , No way . 

 

 Do yourself a favor and do some research of problems , customer service and find one you can put in your hands before you buy one . Keep in mind the semi auto versions are totally different inside in order to work from a closed bolt . One of the things they did when making them semi auto , was to move the height of the bolt so that a full auto bolt can't be installed . In trying to change the existing gun so that it meets the non NFA requirements you end up with something that wasn't designed to work that way . If it had been designed as a semi auto or closed bolt gun from the start , I think it might have worked better . 

Edited by Keyless
Link to comment
I did forget about the insanely hard bolt spring, which is indeed a pain. And the drum mags are a little bit of work to install and remove.

BUT....

I have had absolutely no quality or functioning issues whatever, and I know at least 4 other people that own these (both Kahr and Thompson) and they have never had any issues either. So I wouldn't be discouraged by a single bad review, every gun has a few bad lemons out there somewhere.

And in fact I do still like mine, and doubt I'll ever sell it. It's just cool to look at, share with new shooters, and shoot (and then clean) very rarely.

Just wanted to share the ups and downs with you in case you had visions of shooting often, running it with one hand, or cleaning it up in short order like most other guns. As long as you are aware of the unique properties of this gun then it's still a great investment, just not worth an extreme amount IMHO. Now go get one!
Link to comment

Ok , dream shattered , how bout a AR45 ? :(


Don't get really down on these. Yes they can be a problem in some cases, but what specialty firearm isn't at one point or another.

To address mechanically's comments first. I've shot several Thompsons. I won't say they are hard to control, at least not to the extent I/you can't hit your intended target with one.

Yes, they rise, low left to high right, but if you control the trigger, and it really doesn't take much effort to do so; you can pretty accurately hit man-sized targets with 2 and 3 round bursts.

These are not 50 yard target guns. 50 yard spray yes. But I still think they are controllable to the point of 10-30 yard shots on a person. Maybe not a "placed" shot, but go with the characteristics of the weapon, and trigger/busrt control.

Spray and Pray is meant for the "oh ####" moments that we hope never to be in.

Heavy? Well for me that's subjective. Heavier than a 1911? Yes. Heavier than a normal AR/M16? Maybe, I don't know the weights on both right now.

But for range/out-in-the-woods shooting like we did, I only noticed it being a little heavier with the 100 round drum than the 20 round sticks.

Would I rush out to buy a Thompson/Auto Ordnance? Probably not. I would like to own one, and if I had the money and didn't have to worry about it, I probably would get one.

Just my thoughts on them.

Addendum. Do we now have an auto censor? Just noticed this above had been changed. Edited by hipower
  • Like 1
Link to comment

Heavy? Well for me that's subjective. Heavier than a 1911? Yes. Heavier than a normal AR/M16? Maybe, I don't know the weights on both right now.

But for range/out-in-the-woods shooting like we did, I only noticed it being a little heavier with the 100 round drum than the 20 round sticks.

 

Not much heavier than a normal AR? Only a little heavier? Holy smokes. You must have the strength of Atlas, or perhaps your brain is repressing the horrific memories of the severe weight and recoil. LOL  :eek:
 
Here are the actual stats:
 
 
Gun w/30 rd. stick mag, steel rcvr 13.0 lbs
30 rds. 45 acp 1.4 lbs
TOTAL 14.4 lbs
 
Gun w/50 rd. drum mag, steel rcvr 15.6 lbs
50 rds. 45 acp 2.4 lbs
TOTAL 18.0 lbs
 
Gun w/100 rd. drum mag, steel rcvr 16.8 lbs
100 rds. 45 acp 4.8 lbs
TOTAL 21.6 lbs
 
 
 
Gun w/30 rd. factory mag 6.9 lbs
30 rds. 5.56 NATO 0.8 lbs
TOTAL 7.7 lbs
 
Gun w/60 rd. surefire mag 7.0 lbs
60 rds. 5.56 NATO 1.6 lbs
TOTAL 8.6 lbs
 
Gun w/100 rd. beta drum mag 9.9 lbs
100 rds. 5.56 NATO 2.6 lbs
TOTAL 12.5 lbs
 
So these Tommy guns actually weigh twice or more what an AR15 would weigh with a similar number of cartridges loaded up. Not to mention the additional weight of any extra mags, ammo, and loading tools you would have to lug around. Doesn't prevent them from being fun at the range, but I have never seen a shooter handle the gun and fail to comment about the extreme weight, and even the big guys don't hold it up on target for too long before resting their arms.
Edited by wileecoyote
Link to comment
Ok, you are right. I guess I really just didn't notice the weight. So maybe just faulty memory. It has been a couple of years back.

But weight aside, I stand by the other comments. Maybe if I carried one all day long?
Link to comment

Ok, you are right. I guess I really just didn't notice the weight. So maybe just faulty memory. It has been a couple of years back.

But weight aside, I stand by the other comments. Maybe if I carried one all day long?

If you were lucky enough to shoot an SBR with a short thin barrel and no huge Cutts compensator, and maybe also an aluminum receiver, that would shave about 5-8 lbs. off for sure. But then I would expect the recoil and muzzle climb to be worse, and I would not expect the receiver to hold up well to the battering from the extremely strong action springs. Still lots of fun though, and once the lead starts flying and targets start falling, it's easy to forget about the weight. Edited by wileecoyote
Link to comment

I was REALLY surprised at how difficult these are to control in full-auto. They just walk all over the place. You'd think as heavy as they are, they'd just sit in place while they pop away, but it takes a lot of work to keep them from running away from you. 

It's all about proper stance and burst control otherwise it's pray and spray. Furthermore its a sub sonic pistol cartridge fired from a carbine length barrel so yes its going to be slow. One of the primary things the original Thompson was conceived as being was a trench broom but it just came a bit late for that role.  

If you ever have the chance to do so shoot a Thompson alongside an M&P 5, Stengun and Sterling. Aside from it's crappy folding stock you'll come away the most impressed with the Sterling.

Link to comment

I have to admit it's cool to have, but it is also not as nice or as much fun as I had envisioned. It's extremely heavy unloaded, and an absolute anvil when loaded especially with a full drum. Cleaning is a pain if you do it right, especially the mags. And the bullets travel so slow out the long barrel that you can actually see them on the way to the target. Accuracy is marginal, and decent ammo is not so cheap anymore. Loading the drum mags is tedious, and if you don't do it right they won't run properly.

 

My buddy had one (not in full auto), but it mostly sat in the safe for the reasons you mention.  When we did bring it out to the range, it was the envy of all around us.  It was fun to shoot for a few rounds, but yeah, it's more cool than practical, and the cool wears off faster than you might think. 

 

That being said, if it's something anybody really wants in their collection, and they have the disposable income....why not.  It does have a place in the history of American firearms.

Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

TRADING POST NOTICE

Before engaging in any transaction of goods or services on TGO, all parties involved must know and follow the local, state and Federal laws regarding those transactions.

TGO makes no claims, guarantees or assurances regarding any such transactions.

THE FINE PRINT

Tennessee Gun Owners (TNGunOwners.com) is the premier Community and Discussion Forum for gun owners, firearm enthusiasts, sportsmen and Second Amendment proponents in the state of Tennessee and surrounding region.

TNGunOwners.com (TGO) is a presentation of Enthusiast Productions. The TGO state flag logo and the TGO tri-hole "icon" logo are trademarks of Tennessee Gun Owners. The TGO logos and all content presented on this site may not be reproduced in any form without express written permission. The opinions expressed on TGO are those of their authors and do not necessarily reflect those of the site's owners or staff.

TNGunOwners.com (TGO) is not a lobbying organization and has no affiliation with any lobbying organizations.  Beware of scammers using the Tennessee Gun Owners name, purporting to be Pro-2A lobbying organizations!

×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to the following.
Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Guidelines
 
We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.