Jump to content

I need recommendations for a defensive shotgun.


bird333

Recommended Posts

Buy an AR15.  Seriously.  It's a much, much better choice for defensive purposes, and you can get an incredible deal on one these days.

 

You can find a decent deal on the gun itself.  Then you want an optic, rail system, ect.. Next comes rounds to take it to the range and before long you are staring at the hole in your bank account.

Link to comment

I was looking on Bud's gun shop and I don't think I want to spend $1200 on a VersaMax tactical shotgun.  Especially since I could spend the extra money on an AR.  Also it has a 22" barrel.  It seems most of the shotguns I am interested in have a 18" barrel.  Is 22" too long?  They have a 870 police for about $650.  Is that a reasonable price?  If you guys know of where I can get a better price please speak up. :)

Link to comment
Guest semiautots

That wasnt a grammar correction. Kel-tec doesnt have the best quality on some things, ill wait for ruger to make a better looking copy of it

 

OK, but recommending Ruger for quality is just a little bit funny.  One of the worst quality handguns I ever had was a P89DC.  One of the few guns I have sold.

Link to comment

I'm a fan of any home defense shotgun with the exception of the 500, nothing against owners of such but my observation is of that when you cycle the action after it's new, the weapon becomes a rattle can. Good guns for the money but I just can't get over the 'rattle-rattle' aspect after putting some rounds down range. Good shotguns for the money, 870 or 590/590A1; go with either and you won't be disappointed. If money isn't an issue, get a Saiga, Spas12, FNH SLP, or Benelli M2 or M4. My favorite compromise in between for price/firepower/semi or pump is the Remington 1100 Police, under 1k, can rapidly deploy shot down range and is a pretty simple design.

Edited by whitewolf001
  • Like 1
Link to comment

Which one guys?

 

www.budsgunshop.com/catalog/product_info.php/products_id/56472/Remington+870+Express+Tactical+12ga+18%22+Ghost+Ring+Sights

 

www.budsgunshop.com/catalog/product_info.php/products_id/411540290

 

Also, are these really 7+1 capacity?  They seem like they will only hold 6.   What accessories should I get to go with it?

Link to comment
Guest theconstitutionrocks

I don't have one and I don't necessarily plan on getting one, but anyone have any thoughts about the "Pardner" shotgun usually seen at Wally World? It's supposed to be Chinese manufacture but the reason I find it interesting (besides the price) is that it is chunky, heavy, kinda ugly...any issues with reliability? I was kind of raised to believe that the more rugged the weapon, the better....just askin....thoughts?

Link to comment

... I have never fired a shotgun before BTW.

I couldn't help but notice this remark, and I think it's key to your decision. It's easy to learn to work a pump, but it's also extremely easy to mess up a pump under high stress. If you don't pull the slide all the way back or push all the way forward you'll have a malfunction. If you do get a pump make sure you devote several cases of low-recoil birdshot toward practicing and developing muscle memory. Also, a lightweight "tactical" pump 12-ga kicks like a mule. If you think you can remember to rack the slide properly after receiving a massive kick (along with deafening roar and blinding fireball) about 15 seconds after waking up from a sound sleep, then go for it.

 

If you don't have time, location, or funds for this much practice, then consider a reliable semi-auto. Also consider a 20-ga. A semi-auto is no excuse for not practicing, but if you aren't going to practice anyway then at least get something that does some of the work for you. And a 20-ga, especially a semi-auto version, has considerably less kick than a pump 12. As for power, I keep reading that a 20-Ga delivers the same energy as two simultaneous hits from a .44 Magnum (hardly an under powered round, and we're talking TWO of them). When someone looking for a "defense" shotgun says something like "never fired a shotgun before", I always point them toward the [url=http://www.mossberg.com/products/shotguns/mossberg-international-sa-20/sa-20-tactical]Mossberg SA-20[/url]. They run slightly more than a quality pump 12. A pump 20 would be even cheaper.

 

On the other hand, 20-ga ammo is slightly more expensive, so if you DO plan on shooting a lot then stick with the 12.

 

 

Ammo selection isn't as critical with the shotgun as it is with other systems.  Basically buckshot in #1, 0, 00, or 000 will do a very effective job of stopping threats.  Anything smaller will not reliably achieve the penetration into a human target  necessary to stop a threat.  #4 buck is pretty marginal, IMHO stick with #1 or larger.  Reduced recoil loads are beneficial.. you give up practically nothing in performance and get faster follow up shots.  Pattern your load of choice at 3, 5, 7, 10, 15, 20, and 25 yards.  You need to know where the pellets are going to go at each of those distances.  Maybe stretch it out to 40 or so if you have the room.

 

Birdshot is for practice (you should buy and shoot a lot of it), 3-gun matches (if you do that sorta thing) and, well, birds.  It has no place in an anti-personnel role.  None.  Absolutely none.  The only legitimate reason for using birdshot against people is if you don't have anything else. 

Ammo choice depends on where you live, and where you plan on shooting. The military's go-to shell is 00 buck because they often engage at longer distances (larger pellets carry more energy for longer distances), through barriers (foliage, doors, etc.), and they don't get fired or sued if a few pellets penetrate too far and cause "collateral damage". Many domestic police agencies have switched to #1 buck. With more pellets with suitable penetration, this size causes more damage than 00, plus the smaller pellets are less likely to keep going and kill bystanders. Smaller pellets like #4 don't work well at outdoor distances in military or police situations.

 

If you're out on the ranch and plan on engaging enemies outside (or you are stocking massive quantities of cheap ammo for the zombie apocalypse where you don't have to worry about lawsuits), then go with military 00 with slugs in a side-saddle. But if you don't plan on leaving your yard in a defensive scenario, then you'll never need anything larger than #1. At typical max indoor ranges, #4 is perfectly suitable, even with heavy clothing. If you live in an area surrounded by other houses consider #3 buck to be the max shot size. If you live in an apartment complex where the only thing separating you from your neighbors is a couple of Sheetrock walls, or in a house where friendlies (i.e., kids) may nor may not be where you think they are in the middle of the night, then I HIGHLY recommend dropping down to lead BB or even #2 tungsten bird shot. Yes, the statement, "bird shot is for birds, not bad guys" is valid, but when most people think "bird shot" they're thinking dove or rabbit load, which IS completely unsuitable. And while even the larger bird shot sizes may not meet FBI 12" penetration criteria, at across-the-room distances a bad guy would have a very hard time standing after absorbing a full load of 0.15" #2 pellets.

 

Penetration Testing with various shot loads: http://www.thetruthaboutguns.com/2010/02/robert-farago/shotgun-penetration-with-various-rounds/

Edited by JWKilgore
Link to comment

Which one guys?

 

www.budsgunshop.com/catalog/product_info.php/products_id/56472/Remington+870+Express+Tactical+12ga+18%22+Ghost+Ring+Sights

 

www.budsgunshop.com/catalog/product_info.php/products_id/411540290

 

Also, are these really 7+1 capacity?  They seem like they will only hold 6.   What accessories should I get to go with it?

What side saddle, case and shoulder sling do you guys recommend or does it even really matter?

Edited by bird333
Link to comment
My vote goes to a 590A1... Had one of those for years, even ran it in 3-gun heavy metal. Great shooter, fast to reload due to no loading gate in the way.

I currently use a Benelli M4 for HD, loaded with 3" 000 Remington Buckshot. I preferred 2-3/4" 00 Remington 8 pellet Buckshot in the 590 (it patterned better).
Link to comment

VP Biden says any old double barrel will do!  :rofl:

 

Seriously, any of the above will do.  Me personally, I was sold on a Winchester 1300 Defender many years ago, that is what I have.  Great gun.

 

Man, I miss my 1300 Defender.  Traded for a DSLR for the wife and miss it.  Great running shotty.

Link to comment
  • 3 weeks later...

I have both an 870 and a 590. I use the 870 for HD. It is an express tacticool from Wally Whirl. I much prefer the safety setup on the 590, but on the 870 I keep it hammer down on an empty chamber with the safety off. Rack then attack. I went and did the typical small parts upgrades to the 870 to make it more like a police. Ran an additional 30 bucks in parts or something like that. Extractor, carrier dog spring, mag spring, and follower. Probably not necessary, but for some reason I can't leave anything stock. If I was to only do one, no doubt it would be the carrier dog spring. It is a heavier spring that elevates heavier HD loads like buckshot and slugs more reliably. It is a MUST if you are going to shoot any serious 3" stuff.

Link to comment
  • 4 weeks later...

Buy an AR15.  Seriously.  It's a much, much better choice for defensive purposes, and you can get an incredible deal on one these days.

Can you (or anyone) elaborate on why an AR15 would be a better choice than a shotgun?

Link to comment

Can you (or anyone) elaborate on why an AR15 would be a better choice than a shotgun?


Reduced penetration in walls ( http://how-i-did-it.org/drywall/results.html) , lower recoil, faster follow up shots, more follow up shots before reloading, more practical to suppress, easier to maneuver through doorways and halls... Those were my reasons for making an AR an important part of my HD prep. I still have a shotgun, but it is solely for filling a particular fatal funnel with lead while I am barricaded.
Link to comment

Anything at close range, even a sling shot will go past drywall.

If over penetration is a big concern, you might want to reload and use a smaller powder charge,

but you might not stop the bad guy.

A slug going very slow, made from soft lead just might be the ticket.

It would expand and give up if power fast. That would take a bit testing.

The top left 2 are 525 gr Lyman slug recovered from my sand pit, went in about 6".

You slow it down and you just might have what you are looking for, if you miss it will

penetrate drywall.

[URL=http://s896.photobucket.com/user/redintn/media/casting%20lead/slugbeforeandafter.jpg.html]slugbeforeandafter.jpg[/URL]

Link to comment
If you are talking HD, don't shy away from the mossberg 500. For games maybe. I've seen em run for years in tough hunting situations with little or no maintanence. Also in home or apartment situations, number 4 shot will make anyone reconsider their intentions or worse while minimizing over penetration. Don't get caught up in all the bells and whistles and do take a course especially since you have no experience.
Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

TRADING POST NOTICE

Before engaging in any transaction of goods or services on TGO, all parties involved must know and follow the local, state and Federal laws regarding those transactions.

TGO makes no claims, guarantees or assurances regarding any such transactions.

THE FINE PRINT

Tennessee Gun Owners (TNGunOwners.com) is the premier Community and Discussion Forum for gun owners, firearm enthusiasts, sportsmen and Second Amendment proponents in the state of Tennessee and surrounding region.

TNGunOwners.com (TGO) is a presentation of Enthusiast Productions. The TGO state flag logo and the TGO tri-hole "icon" logo are trademarks of Tennessee Gun Owners. The TGO logos and all content presented on this site may not be reproduced in any form without express written permission. The opinions expressed on TGO are those of their authors and do not necessarily reflect those of the site's owners or staff.

TNGunOwners.com (TGO) is not a lobbying organization and has no affiliation with any lobbying organizations.  Beware of scammers using the Tennessee Gun Owners name, purporting to be Pro-2A lobbying organizations!

×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to the following.
Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Guidelines
 
We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.